On Thursday, November 5, 2009, U.S. District Judge Joseph H. McKinley Jr. denied a preliminary injunction sought by a group of tobacco companies as part of a lawsuit they brought in August arguing new federal tobacco regulations violate their right to free speech. As Michael Felberbaum reports for the Associated Press, the ruling last Thursday does seem to indicate the companies have little chance of prevailing in their suit.
The companies in question are challenging the provisions of a new law that gave the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) new regulatory authority over tobacco. The law, which passed in June, is called the Family Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act. In his decision, Judge McKinley saw no reason to block the provision while the lawsuit is ongoing.
The tobacco companies were naturally disappointed in the ruling, while the FDA spokeswoman Kathleen Quinn states in the AP article that the FDA is “pleased that the court ‘denied this attempt to keep FDA from enforcing crucial public health legislation.’” According to Floyd Abrams, an attorney representing Lorillard (maker of Newport brand cigarettes), Judge McKinley must ultimately determine if each regulation being challenged by the companies violates free speech. The lawsuit does not challenge the FDA’s authority to regulate tobacco.
The law will take full effect over three years. Under the statute the companies are barred from using “light” and “low tar” in their labeling. Additionally, companies can no longer make candy flavored products and they must include new graphic warnings over cartoon images. The companies argue this law “prohibits them from using ‘color lettering, trademarks, logos or any other imagery in most advertisements, including virtually all point-of-sale and direct-mail advertisements.’” The companies also complain the law prevents them from ‘“making truthful statements about their products in scientific, public policy and political debates.”’
The FDA maintains the new marketing regulations do not restrict free speech, and, in fact they serve the health interests of the public.
To read the Felberbaum article click here.
Posted: 11/09/09
Search This Blog
Content Areas
- Administrative Law (36)
- Agricultural Economics (184)
- Agritourism (30)
- Alternative Dispute Resolution (17)
- Animal Feeding Operations (136)
- Animal Identification (26)
- Animal Law (39)
- Animal Welfare (158)
- Announcement (259)
- Antitrust (1)
- Aquaculture (42)
- Bankruptcy (15)
- Biosecurity (32)
- Biotechnology (132)
- Blogs (18)
- Business Organizations (1)
- Checkoff Programs (11)
- Clean Air Act (5)
- Clean Water Act (113)
- Climate Change (147)
- Commercial Transactions (24)
- Commodity Programs (94)
- Congress (310)
- Conservation Programs (77)
- Cooperatives (16)
- Corporate Farming Laws (11)
- Country of Origin Labeling (43)
- Crop Insurance (92)
- Disaster Assistance Programs (17)
- Drought (24)
- Endangered Species Act (11)
- Environmental Law (268)
- EPA (139)
- Estate Planning and Taxation (28)
- Farm Bill (202)
- FDA (97)
- Finance and Credit (76)
- Food Labeling (176)
- Food Law (162)
- Food Safety (373)
- Food Security (18)
- Forestry (26)
- GIPSA (12)
- Hemp (11)
- House Agriculture Committee (17)
- Immigration (10)
- International Law and Organizations (175)
- International Trade (234)
- Labor (57)
- Landowner Liability (38)
- Leases (13)
- Local Food Systems (88)
- Marketing Orders (18)
- NALC Resource (20)
- NASDA (2)
- National Organic Program (42)
- Nutrition Programs (118)
- Packers and Stockyards Act (30)
- Perishable Agricultural Commodities (27)
- Pesticides (70)
- Production Contracts (19)
- Renewable Energy (185)
- Research (16)
- Right to Farm (13)
- Rural Development (111)
- Secured Transactions (12)
- Senate Ag Committee (20)
- Specialty Crops (30)
- Sustainable Agriculture (106)
- Urbanization and Agriculture (46)
- USDA (600)
- USDA HWFRCP (8)
- Water Law (136)
Related Blogs
- AgMag by the EWG
- Agricultural Law - The official blog of the AALS section on agricultural law
- AgWired
- Animal ID Systems
- Arkansas Electric Energy Law Blog
- Beginning Farmers
- Blog for Rural America
- Blogiculture
- Corn Commentary
- Dairy Cast
- DTN Ag Policy Blog
- DTN's Minding Ag’s Business
- eXtension's Blog
- Farm Aid
- Farm Future's D.C. Dialogue by Jacqui Fatka
- Farm Future's This Business of Farming Blog by Mike Wilson
- Farmer-Veteran Coalition
- FarmersReport.com
- FarmPolicy.com
- Food-Label-Compliance.com
- InfoFarm: The National Ag Library's Blog
- Iowa Farmers Union
- Kentucky Journal of Equine, Agriculture & Natural Resource Law's Blog
- Marketmaker's
- Marler Blog
- Nebraska Corn Kernels
- Obama Foodorama
- Ohio Agricultural Law Blog
- Oklahoma Agriculture Blog
- Rincker Law's Agriculture Blog
- Southeast AgNET
- The Farm Gate
- The Rural Blog
- The Westerner
- U.S. Food Policy
- Washington View
- What to Eat